Muffin was in quite the party-animal mood. "One, two, three, now!" he counted down, then the four of us grabbed a glass and downed our shots. The tequila burned through my throat like I'd swallowed a match and I did my best not to choke out loud. Anika wasn't as successful.

 

"Fuck, that's strong," she coughed. Mark patted her on the back to help her swallow, and the four of us settled into the couch, Muffin snuggling with me and Mark with Anika. We chatted for a little bit, then Muffin was eager to move things along.

 

"So I've got a couple of bedrooms set up for us, one at either end of the hall," Muffin announced to the group. Looking at me he said, "Should be go to our room and get comfortable?"

 

"Actually Muffin, Crystal and I have a surprise for you. Are you guys game?" Anika asked.

 

"Oh yeah?" Muffin said, thrown a little off balance that I hadn't immediately said 'Yes,' to his suggestion, and curious to know what we had in store for them. "Sure! Surprises are a good thing." Mark added.

 

"Cool! We'll be right back," Anika said as she stood from the sofa and grabbed my hand as I grabbed my bag. As we walked into Muffin's master bedroom I could feel the guys watching us. They poured themselves another shot and sipped, waiting for the show to begin as they watched the bedroom door swing closed.

 

Inside Muffin's bedroom, I opened my handbag and pulled out the two ponytail anal plugs we'd bought especially for tonight. We'd tried them on the day we bought them, and decided that I would get the blond one, to compliment my brunette hair, and Anika would have the black one because she was blond. With a little bit of Wicked Jelle anal lubricant the hourglass shape of the plugs fit perfectly into our behinds, although I have to admit that the four-inch plug length took a little getting used to. The horsehair of the tail was about two feet long and swished behind our knees when we walked.

 

We stripped off our t-shirts, jean shorts and panties and tossed them into a corner of the bedroom.

 

"Bend over and grab your ankles," I smiled at Anika as I spread a little Jelle onto the tip of her plug. She did as she was told and I slowly worked the hourglass shape of the butt plug into her hole, widening her until I heard the tell-tale pop as the anal plug nestled itself inside her. "Good?" I asked, wanting to make sure that it didn't fall out of her behind.

 

Anika stood and wiggled her butt, making the black horsehair swish behind her legs. She jiggled her butt cheeks from side to side, not used to something that size being in her ass, then said, "Perfect. Your turn."

 

I squeezed some Jelle onto my fingers, spread it over my butt hole, and bent over and spread my cheeks for her. I felt myself open up as she guided the anal plug into me, felt my hole stretch to accept the widest part of the plug, then 'pop' as the plug settled into place. We were good to go. I stood up, shaking my ass to make the blond horsehair swirl. "Giddy up!" I said, as we both laughed.

 

We took one last look at ourselves in the full-length mirror Muffin had by his bed. Since becoming full-time escorts last week we'd been hitting the tanning booth as much as possible and now had no tan lines whatsoever. We both did the Brazilian groom so the only hair we had was on the top of our heads, and now of course, the ponytails. Satisfied, we walked back into the living room holding hands, ready to give Mark and Muffin the ride of their lives.

 

"Holy shit!" Muffin exclaimed as we padded nude and smooth into the room, stopping a few feet in front of the guys, and Mark added an appreciative "Fuck me!"

 

"You guys like what you see?" Anika asked, knowing damn well the answer was 'Fuck yes!' We turned around and bent over, wriggled our behinds to make the horsehair twirl back and forth, then stood and turned to face the two men.

 

"Ride 'em cowboy!" Muffin exclaimed, and started to stand, ready to herd me into his bedroom. But Anika and I had other plans.

 

"Hang on big boy," Anika raised a finger to stop Muffin in his tracks. He paused, then plopped back down into the sofa, a confused look on his face and a hard on between his legs. I could see that Mark was equally as erect.

 

"You two want to play a game with us?" I asked. The guys looked at each other, gave us a blank look, then nodded their heads, not exactly sure what to say.

 

"Then come with us," Anika said as she grasped onto Mark's hard on through his pants. I held Muffin's clothed erection and we led the two men by their dicks into the master bedroom and sat them on the edge of the king sized bed. They looked at us expectantly as we stood naked in front of them, our ponytail anal plugs swishing behind our legs.

 

"Why don't you two get comfortable?" I said, and the guys immediately stripped, their erections homing in on us, then sat back down.

 

"So here's what we're going to do," Anika began. "We're going to have two teams. Muffin, you're with Crystal, and Mark, you're with me."

 

I continued the instructions. "Anika and I are going to get on the edge of the bed and you're going to fuck us five times, doggy style, then switch, back and forth, until one of you cums. And we're going to do our best to make the other guy cum."

 

"I like that!" Muffin interjected, stroking himself to get harder, then paused when I held up my hand.

 

Anika moved closer to Muffin sitting on the bed, so that her nipples just barely brushed his cheek and looked down into his face. "But, whichever one of you guys cums first, loses."

 

"Oh," Mark said, realizing that in order to win our little game a combination of stamina, endurance and self control would be required from him and Muffin. And that we would do our best to make them lose all three.

 

"And if one of us gets pregnant the other team gets bonus points," Anika added. "So Muffin, if you knock Crystal up then me and Mark get extra points, and if Mark gets me pregnant then you and her get extra points."